Using Runs Relative To Average To Determine The Best All Around Careers (Part 2)

Click here to see Part 1.

I thought of another way to measure this. Since the  running and fielding ratings were converted to rate stats to be like the hitting stat (OPS+), and that average was 100 once the geometric mean was applied, I could use 80 as replacement level. Then 80 was subtracted from each player's rating and multiplied by the number of seasons they played (a full season was 700 PAs). Then that would give me an all-around rating above replacement level. That way, guys whose careers ended early did not have the advantage of missing their decline years. So here is the top 25

Rank	Player	OPS+	Run	Field	Rating	Seasons	WAR
1	Barry Bonds	182	102.2	110.9	127.2	18.0	850.5
2	Hank Aaron	155	101.9	105.2	118.4	19.9	764.1
3	Willie Mays	156	104.4	111.6	122.0	17.9	749.8
4	Babe Ruth	206	98.4	105.5	128.8	15.2	740.1
5	Ty Cobb	168	102.6	99.3	119.6	18.7	739.9
6	Stan Musial	159	99.2	102.6	117.3	18.2	678.2
7	Tris Speaker	157	99.4	105.7	118.1	17.1	652.7
8	Carl Yastrzemski	130	99.2	110.2	112.4	20.0	647.3
9	Honus Wagner	151	101.7	105.3	117.3	16.8	626.5
10	Rickey Henderson	127	108.3	103.3	112.4	19.1	617.6
11	Frank Robinson	154	101.8	100.9	116.5	16.8	611.7
12	Mel Ott	155	98.9	103.0	116.4	16.2	590.0
13	Ted Williams	190	99.5	96.6	122.2	14.0	589.5
14	Eddie Collins	142	102.1	101.7	113.8	17.2	581.1
15	Al Kaline	134	101.9	110.2	114.6	16.6	572.6
16	Rogers Hornsby	175	98.5	104.1	121.5	13.5	561.5
17	Lou Gehrig	179	98.4	99.5	120.5	13.8	558.9
18	Mickey Mantle	172	103.5	95.9	119.4	14.2	558.2
19	Alex Rodriguez	143	103.5	101.2	114.4	16.2	557.0
20	Albert Pujols	162	100.5	111.8	122.0	13.2	555.0
21	Pete Rose	118	100.0	96.5	104.3	22.7	552.7
22	Eddie Murray	129	98.7	103.3	109.5	18.3	540.4
23	Nap Lajoie	150	98.4	105.9	116.0	14.9	538.3
24	George Brett	135	101.8	102.7	112.1	16.6	533.2
25	Mike Schmidt	147	99.2	109.8	116.9	14.4	531.1

Click here to see the complete rankings.