Tuesday, August 4, 2026

Players who were hitting .400+ while reaching the batting title qualifier at some point in a year they ended up below .400

I used bases.chat, the baseball AI program created by fellow SABR member Ted Ingram, to create this list. The qualifiers for different time periods were used since this rule has changed a few times. See Rate Stats Qualifiers from mlb.com.

For Rogers Hornsby in 1921 there were 2 games left in the season. After 584 ABs & 664 PAs he had a .402 batting average. The Cardinals had no chance to make the post season. Yet he played the last 2 games of the season. He went 0 for 8 and his average fell below .400 to .397. 

Player

Qualifier

Season

Final AVG

Peak AVG

Last Day at .400

Burkett

60% team G

1899

0.395

0.405

9/4/1899

McGraw

60% team G

1899

0.391

0.404

8/26/1899

Speaker

60% team G

1912

0.383

0.405

8/31/1912

Joe Jackson

60% team G

1913

0.373

0.409

8/4/1913

Ty Cobb

60% team G

1915

0.369

0.400

8/3/1915

Speaker

60% team G

1916

0.388

0.401

8/13/1916

Speaker

100 G

1920

0.388

0.421

8/16/1920

Heilmann

100 G

1921

0.394

0.419

9/24/1921

Hornsby

100 G

1921

0.397

0.415

10/1/1921

Ruth

100 G

1923

0.394

0.405

9/1/1923

Ruth

100 G

1924

0.378

0.408

8/16/1924

BaHerman

100 G

1929

0.383

0.414

9/1/1929

Klein

100 G

1930

0.385

0.407

8/16/1930

BaHerman

100 G

1930

0.393

0.405

8/18/1930

Vaughan

100 G

1935

0.385

0.407

9/10/1935

Medwick

100 G

1937

0.374

0.402

8/19/1937

DiMaggio

100 G

1939

0.381

0.409

9/10/1939