Using Runs Above Average To Determine The Best All Around Careers

Using the Baseball Reference Play Index, I called up all the seasons with at least 0.1 in each of the following stats: fielding runs (Rfield), base running runs (Rbaser) and batting runs (Rbat). Those are all above average (no seasons came up from 1876-1885, maybe because they don't have SB data for those years).

Then all three stats were multiplied by each other. Then I took the cube root to get the geometric mean. Each player then had their individual seasons added up. Here are the top 25

1	Willie Mays	197.0106
2	Rickey Henderson	174.8769
3	Barry Bonds	150.7554
4	Al Kaline	111.9025
5	Hank Aaron	103.7591
6	Roberto Clemente	90.52869
7	Kenny Lofton	87.87493
8	Jeff Bagwell	87.33088
9	Chase Utley	85.69787
10	Larry Walker	84.28949
11	Alex Rodriguez	82.69314
12	Albert Pujols	80.61014
13	Honus Wagner	79.79136
14	Eddie Collins	78.96287
15	Ichiro Suzuki	76.79083
16	Frank Robinson	76.45436
17	Carl Yastrzemski	73.22376
18	Jackie Robinson	72.24035
19	Ty Cobb	69.82541
20	Scott Rolen	68.84928
21	Max Carey	68.3932
22	Frankie Frisch	67.90673
23	Joe Morgan	65.48298
24	Ken Griffey2	65.37055
25	George Brett	65.01004

Click here to see the complete rankings