Part 1 was actually Which Players Had The Most Uncharacteristically Good Seasons? What I did there was to find all the players who had 10+ seasons of 400+ PAs and then see who had the biggest difference between their average (offensive winning percentage) OWP and their highest. Here I simply looked at their best OWP vs. their 2nd best. Jeter actually had .715 in 2006. That would drop him down to about 87th place out of about 500 guys. So there could be some other big ones since then but I will need to look into that. I also looked at this including everyone with 3+ seasons of 400+ PAs. I will post that if I get a chance or you can email me about it.