I had Stathead call up all the guys with 3,000+ PAs from ages 25-32 and ranked them by OPS+ (Judge played a bit at age 24 but under 100 PAs). A link to the results is below the table along with a link where the cutoff was 2,000.
Judge is 10th. If we had a cutoff of 4,000 PAs, he would be 8th. So an outstanding career so far. The table has the top 25. There were 57 players who had an OPS+ of 150 or higher.
|
Rk |
Player |
OPS+ |
PA |
|
1 |
Babe Ruth |
220 |
4955 |
|
2 |
Rogers Hornsby |
190 |
5022 |
|
3 |
Ty Cobb |
190 |
4560 |
|
4 |
Ted Williams |
190 |
3824 |
|
5 |
Lou Gehrig |
187 |
5571 |
|
6 |
Mickey Mantle |
186 |
4489 |
|
7 |
Barry Bonds |
181 |
5015 |
|
8 |
Dan Brouthers |
178 |
4204 |
|
9 |
Mike Trout |
177 |
3089 |
|
10 |
Aaron Judge |
176 |
4228 |
|
11 |
Stan Musial |
172 |
5499 |
|
12 |
Jimmie Foxx |
171 |
5206 |
|
13 |
Johnny Mize |
170 |
3099 |
|
14 |
Nap Lajoie |
169 |
4046 |
|
15 |
Albert Pujols |
168 |
5375 |
|
16 |
Roger Connor |
168 |
4257 |
|
17 |
Ed Delahanty |
166 |
4855 |
|
18 |
Honus Wagner |
166 |
4774 |
|
19 |
Dick Allen |
166 |
4255 |
|
20 |
Frank Thomas |
166 |
5147 |
|
21 |
Willie McCovey |
166 |
4696 |
|
22 |
Frank Robinson |
166 |
5005 |
|
23 |
Tris Speaker |
164 |
5016 |
|
24 |
Jeff Bagwell |
164 |
5172 |
|
25 |
Henry Aaron |
164 |
5370 |
Rankings with a 3,000 PA cutoff.
Rankings with a 2,000 PA cutoff.
Here are the OPS+ leaders from 2022-24 with 1,000+ PAs
|
Player |
OPS+ |
PA |
|
Aaron Judge |
206 |
1858 |
|
Yordan Alvarez |
176 |
1692 |
|
Shohei Ohtani |
173 |
1996 |
|
Juan Soto |
160 |
2085 |
|
Freddie Freeman |
155 |
2076 |
|
Mookie Betts |
151 |
1848 |
Only players to have at least a 200 OPS+ from ages 30-32 with 1,000+ PAs
Aaron Judge 206
Babe Ruth 203
Cobb is 3rd at 190
