Players who hit a HR off multiple Hall of Famers in the same game

This was posted by BB Ref. The link itself then has links to the box scores of each game (I also supply the links below with the pitcher involved)

https://bsky.app/profile/baseball-reference.com/post/3lswfm3rrp224

Dave Parker, Ruth, Mantle, Ted Williams, Billy Williams, Jackie Jensen, Rickey Henderson, Eduardo Perez, B.J. Surhoff.

 

Pitchers that appear twice on this list are Dennis Eckersley, Bob Feller and Bob Lemon. 

 

Eduardo Pérez in 2005 — the pitchers were Randy Johnson & Mariano Rivera. (The HR off of Rivera tied the game in the bottom of the 9th giving Rivera a blown save-All 3 of the Rays runs in the first 9 innings were driven in on the Perez HRs and they won 4-3 in 11 innings)

 

B.J. Surhoff in 1998 — the pitchers were Pedro Martínez & Dennis Eckersley. (Two days later Surhoff would hit the last HR that Eckersley would give up in his career-the last 2 were by Surhoff).

 

Rickey Henderson in 1987 — the pitchers were Phil Niekro & Steve Carlton. (The HR off of Carlton was a 2 out 2 run HR and it gave the Yankees a 1 run lead in the top of the 9th but they lost in the bottom of the inning).

 

Dave Parker in 1985 — the pitchers were Dennis Eckersley and Lee Smith. (The HR off of Smith was a grand slam)

 

Billy Williams in 1967 — the pitchers were Juan Marichal & Gaylord Perry. (The HR off of Perry tied the game in the bottom of the 9th)

 

Ted Williams in 1957 — the pitchers were Early Wynn & Bob Lemon. (Williams hit 3 HRs in this game, 2 off of Wynn)

 

Mickey Mantle in 1956 — the pitchers were Bob Lemon & Bob Feller. (The HR off of Lemon was a grand slam)

 

Jackie Jensen in 1954 — the pitchers were Bob Feller & Hal Newhouser. (this was the last career HR allowed by Newhouser)

 

Babe Ruth in 1928 — the pitchers were Red Faber & Ted Lyons.