Aaron Judge had a 1.207 OPS in a 200 game span from 4-3-24 to 5-21-25. Where does that rank since 2005?

First. I am starting with 2005 to be in the post Barry Bonds era (2004 was his last great season).

Here are the top 200 game spans since 2005 that I found using Stathead.

Judge 1.207   (4/3/24 to 5/20/21)
Pujols 1.166  (2008-9)
Yelich 1.134  (2018-20) 
Cabrera 1.127  (2012-13)
Judge 1.123   (4/20/22 to 8/2/23)

Trout 1.115  (2018-9)

Chipper Jones 1.104  (2006-8)

Jose Bautista 1.103  (2010-11)

Pujols 1.102  (2005-6) 

Click here to see the search results.

Many of these players have more than one span of 200 games with a 1.100+ OPS. They mostly overlap and the ones listed above are the highest for each guy, accept for Judge and Pujols who each have two completely separate 200 game spans. 

The cases listed above are the only ones since 2005 of 1.100 or higher. Pujols had an additional span of 1.108 during 2003-4. 

 

Update May 27: Judge has a 1.209 OPS in the 200 games from 2024-04-09 to 2025-05-26