Top 15 in runs created in All-Star games for each league from 1950-82

I used the simple Bill James formula of

 (Times On Base X Total Bases)/PA 

I used the Stathead Game Finder to get all the game lines for anyone who played in an All-Star game in this period. The I had Excel calculate subtotals for the relevant stats for each player.

Here is the top 15 in the NL:

Player NL	RC
Willie Mays	14.63
Stan Musial	9.88
Steve Garvey	9.63
Johnny Bench	7.86
Ted Kluszewski	6.50
Ernie Banks	6.17
Mike Schmidt	6.00
Willie Davis	6.00
Ken Boyer	5.92
Roberto Clemente	5.50
Enos Slaughter	4.67
Ken Griffey	4.50
Gary Carter	4.44
Henry Aaron	4.28
Joe Morgan	4.26

Now the AL

Player AL	RC
Al Kaline	7.13
Brooks Robinson	7.02
Harmon Killebrew	6.07
Mickey Mantle	5.85
Carl Yastrzemski	5.68
Nellie Fox	5.46
Fred Lynn	4.67
Reggie Jackson	4.55
Rod Carew	4.33
Rocky Colavito	4.15
Al Rosen	3.86
Leon Wagner	3.64
Bill Skowron	3.27
Ted Williams	3.23
Ken Singleton	3.00

Now the top 30 combining the two leagues

Player	RC	Lg
Willie Mays	14.63	NL
Stan Musial	9.88	NL
Steve Garvey	9.63	NL
Johnny Bench	7.86	NL
Al Kaline	7.13	AL
Brooks Robinson	7.02	AL
Ted Kluszewski	6.50	NL
Ernie Banks	6.17	NL
Harmon Killebrew	6.07	AL
Mike Schmidt	6.00	NL
Willie Davis	6.00	NL
Ken Boyer	5.92	NL
Mickey Mantle	5.85	AL
Carl Yastrzemski	5.68	AL
Roberto Clemente	5.50	NL
Nellie Fox	5.46	AL
Enos Slaughter	4.67	NL
Fred Lynn	4.67	AL
Reggie Jackson	4.55	AL
Ken Griffey	4.50	NL
Gary Carter	4.44	NL
Rod Carew	4.33	AL
Henry Aaron	4.28	NL
Joe Morgan	4.26	NL
Rocky Colavito	4.15	AL
Lee Mazzilli	4.00	NL
Tim McCarver	4.00	NL
Bobby Bonds	4.00	NL
Al Rosen	3.86	AL
Frank Robinson	3.69	NL