Ohtani is 11th in the AL average game score for pitchers with 5+ starts and 9th in OPS+ for guys with 100+ PAs

Here are the ranks from the Baseball Reference Play Index.

Player	GmScA
Justin Verlander	71.8
Gerrit Cole	69.8
Corey Kluber	66.7
Luis Severino	64.4
Charlie Morton	63.5
Chris Sale	63.4
Trevor Cahill	62.9
James Paxton	61.8
Trevor Bauer	61.5
Blake Snell	60.7
Shohei Ohtani	59.5

Player	OPS+
Mookie Betts	208
Mike Trout	203
Manny Machado	172
Aaron Judge	170
J.D. Martinez	167
Jose Ramirez	167
Gleyber Torres	157
Mitch Moreland	155
Shohei Ohtani	154
Francisco Lindor	151