The table below shows all the teammates since 1900 who each had at least a 170 OPS+ in the same season and qualified for the batting title. Ruth & Gehrig did it 6 times, more than the rest combined. Gehrig had 165 in 1929. Ruth had 193. Aaron (182) and Mathews (168) came close in 1959. Cobb & Heilmann each had 169 in 1922. Data from Baseball Reference.
| Player |
OPS+ |
Year |
Tm |
| Babe Ruth |
225 |
1927 |
NYY |
| Lou Gehrig |
220 |
1927 |
NYY |
| Babe Ruth |
206 |
1928 |
NYY |
| Lou Gehrig |
193 |
1928 |
NYY |
| Babe Ruth |
211 |
1930 |
NYY |
| Lou Gehrig |
203 |
1930 |
NYY |
| Babe Ruth |
218 |
1931 |
NYY |
| Lou Gehrig |
194 |
1931 |
NYY |
| Babe Ruth |
201 |
1932 |
NYY |
| Lou Gehrig |
181 |
1932 |
NYY |
| Babe Ruth |
176 |
1933 |
NYY |
| Lou Gehrig |
177 |
1933 |
NYY |
| Joe Medwick |
182 |
1937 |
STL |
| Johnny Mize |
173 |
1937 |
STL |
| Kevin Mitchell |
192 |
1989 |
SFG |
| Will Clark |
175 |
1989 |
SFG |
| Albert Pujols |
173 |
2004 |
STL |
| Jim Edmonds |
171 |
2004 |
STL |
| J.D. Martinez |
182 |
2018 |
BOS |
| Mookie Betts |
193 |
2018 |
BOS |